Why Nonprofits Need Professional Communicators: The Key to Effective Storytelling and Long-Term Donor Engagement

Nonprofits often struggle to decide between using volunteers or hiring professional communicators such as producers, photographers, and videographers. While it may be tempting to use volunteers to save money, relying on professionals can significantly impact the effectiveness and sustainability of a nonprofit’s mission, especially regarding communication strategies.

Stanley is doing a two-camera interview in Lisbon, Portugal.

Why Nonprofits Should Use Professionals in Communications:

  1. Impactful Storytelling: Professional communicators bring a high level of expertise in crafting stories that resonate emotionally with audiences. This is critical for nonprofits, as compelling stories help donors connect with the cause more deeply. Organizations like Charity Water have used professional storytelling to engage supporters with authentic, emotionally charged narratives, which have led to higher donor trust and more significant contributions.
  2. Consistency in Branding: One of the critical aspects of maintaining donor trust is having a consistent and professional brand image. Volunteers, while passionate, may not have the experience needed to maintain uniform messaging across platforms. Professionals are trained to handle multi-channel strategies and create brand guides that ensure the nonprofit’s identity is cohesive, which enhances long-term donor relationships​.
  3. Efficiency and Focus: Professionals are equipped with the tools and knowledge to handle the complexities of media production efficiently. From pre-production planning to post-production editing, they streamline the process, ensuring deadlines and resources are effectively utilized. On the other hand, volunteers may lack the necessary time and expertise, leading to delays and suboptimal outcomes.
  4. Audience Engagement: Nonprofits need to engage their supporters through various media channels. A professional photographer or videographer can capture high-quality content that tells a story visually, engaging audiences in ways that statistics alone cannot. This engagement often leads to higher donations, as supporters can see the direct impact of their contributions.
  5. Avoiding Risk: Without trained professionals, nonprofits risk producing content that could be perceived as amateurish or even misleading. Poor-quality media can damage a nonprofit’s reputation, making it appear untrustworthy. Moreover, volunteers may not always understand the nuances of sensitive storytelling, which could inadvertently lead to legal or ethical issues, further undermining the organization’s credibility.
Stanley’s interview setup with Dr. Jack Sorg for the Moldova Medical Short-Term Missions Team

Risks of Not Using Trained Communications Professionals:

  • Brand Dilution: Inconsistent messaging and visuals can dilute the nonprofit’s brand, making it harder to differentiate from competitors. Without professional oversight, the organization’s voice may lack clarity, causing confusion among supporters and stakeholders.
  • Lost Donor Engagement: Volunteers might need to gain the skills to create media that effectively capture the attention of potential donors. This could result in less engagement on social media, fewer website visits, and, ultimately, a decline in fundraising​.
  • Long-term Costs: While volunteers may seem cost-effective initially, the long-term costs of ineffective communication—such as lower donor retention or decreased fundraising—can outweigh the short-term savings. Correcting poorly executed media projects can be more expensive than getting it right the first time with professionals.

Conclusion: For nonprofits, communication is more than just delivering a message; it’s about connecting with donors and supporters. Hiring professional photographers, videographers, and producers ensures this communication is done effectively, increasing monetary donations and volunteer involvement. While volunteers are invaluable in many areas, the role of skilled professionals in nonprofit communications should not be underestimated, as it is a crucial part of building a sustainable and prosperous organization.

With over two decades of experience organizing the Southwestern Photojournalism Conference and creating mission Storytelling Abroad Workshops, I’ve seen firsthand professionals’ vital role in nonprofit communications. From 1990 to 2024, I worked with both amateurs and professionals, particularly in mission photography. Through this, I firmly believe that organizations should prioritize hiring professionals for storytelling, especially for projects to raise funds or build public engagement. Professionals bring expertise, consistency, and the ability to craft impactful narratives. Once these critical stories are in place, volunteers can work alongside them, learning and contributing to internal projects. This approach ensures the highest quality in external-facing communication while nurturing the next generation of storytellers.

A Journey in Storytelling: Hannah Strayer’s Mission to Togo and Beyond

I first met Hannah Strayer in 2015 during our Storytellers Abroad Missions Multimedia Workshop in Romania. At the time, she was already deep into her missionary journey. Hannah had a passion for photography, and this workshop introduced her to the world of storytelling, where words and visuals come together to create compelling narratives.

During the 2015 Storytellers Abroad Workshop in Romania, Hannah Strayer received guidance from storyteller coach James Dockery while Jon Franz worked diligently on his project beside them.

Her enthusiasm for storytelling led her to attend several more ABWE’s Storytellers Abroad workshops, traveling to places like Nicaragua, Peru, and Togo. With each experience, Hannah grew in her craft, eventually attending language school to learn French in preparation for her move to Togo, West Africa, where she would serve as a full-time missionary media specialist.

However, Hannah didn’t join a large missions team with on-field mentors. To continue improving her skills and gaining valuable feedback, she kept participating in more workshops, working closely with coaches who helped refine her storytelling abilities.

Hannah Strayer conducts a video interview with Samweli Chacha, capturing his story with the help of missionary Aaron Boon, who translates from Swahili to English for the storytelling project in Tanzania on September 7, 2024.

One of the stories we worked on in Tanzania revolved around a key challenge facing missionaries there: securing visas from the government. A vital part of that solution was the new farm established by the local missionary team. The farm helped with visa renewals and trained pastors in farming techniques, providing them with the tools to support their families while leading their churches.

One of the pastors we featured was Samweli Chacha, who attended The Biblical Center for Pastors. He was thrilled to discover the bonus of learning agriculture alongside his studies. His story is familiar in Tanzania, where many pastors are called to lead churches with little formal education. Often, pastors need a secondary job to support themselves, and without proper income, they may have to abandon their role in the church to care for their families.

Samweli’s story is a testament to the holistic approach the missionaries are taking—addressing both spiritual and financial needs.

Watch the video to see how these efforts are making a difference for Samweli and other pastors striving to serve their communities in Tanzania.